| UFAs | TH's Thoughts | What TH would do |
| Lee Stempniak | Stempniak found some chemistry with Kunitz and Crosby, but ultimately was a 3rd liner in Calgary, so he seems like he was another scrub who worked hard enough to fit in with Crosby's hard-working, blue collar style. He made 2.5 mil last season, and is still in his prime at just 31, but just barely. He might be salivating at the chance to stay with a playoff team, but more likely he'll want to test the market for one. | Float Stempniak an offer of 1 year in the 1-1.5 mil range. If he takes it, great. If not, no big loss. |
| Jussi Jokinen | The Jus was loose all over the playoffs, and leading up to them. He was scoring goals, and big goals at that, and really showed up in the playoffs. He played so well that...he played himself out of town. Jokinen is a great, versatile (can play any forward position well) player with speed and some finishing ability. He was pulling second line minutes a lot of the season with Malkin and Neal, and was doing so with a 3 mil contact (though Carolina retained some of his salary). 3 Million is probably where I would want the salary to be for a second line winger, but like I said Jussi played his way out of town. | Thank him for his time, but let him walk. Someone is going to ridiculously overpay for him this offseason. |
| Taylor Pyatt | Pyatt was a mid-season acquisition who filled the need for a big body (6'4"), but not for the speed this team plays with. We didn't see too much of the 32 year old, and rightfully so. He just wasn't a good fit for the team, I feel like the pro scouts dropped the ball on this one, and the fact he made 1.55 mil this season (the Penguins were only on the hook for part of it)? Absurd. Maybe he fits somewhere else, but this was another failed experiment. | Give him a cardboard box and a sign that says 'will play hockey for food' on his way out. |
| Marcel Goc | Goc is a player I really would like to see back, but it's not really feasible. He didn't get too much of a chance with the Penguins, missing a good deal of time with an ankle injury shortly after arriving in Pittsburgh. A superb faceoff man who had some offensive flair earlier in his career, he's more of a two-way forward these days. His salary last season was about 1.7 mil, and at 30 he still has something left in the tank. The problem comes down to playing that much for what would be a 4th line center (unless you want Crosby and Malkin on the top line all the time next season). | If Sutter says he wants out or if he want insane money, quaify him, then talk to Goc, see if he will stay in town for 1.3-1.5 million for a couple seasons for a chance at a cup--again, only if sutter won't play ball. |
| Tanner Glass | If the Penguins are really committed to playoff hockey and being tough to play against, resigning Glass is a must. He seemed to be the only person willing to hit someone on the forecheck at times this season, something the Penguins could have benefited from against the Rangers. He's not the fastest, but has decent speed. While he's not going to score in bunches, he's a heart and soul player and hard worker, who made 1.1 mil per year seem like a good deal for the Pens. | Keeping Glass is a must. He deserves a raise, so maybe float him an offer in the 1.3mil range for 2 season, perhaps throw a few bonuses in for stat performance as an incentive. |
| Chuck Kobasew | Not much to say here. He fooled everyone in the preseason with some awesome play, then ended up in the minors to finish the season. | Maybe we should give the cardboard box and sign to Kobasew, not Pyatt. I think he's done in the NHL. |
| Joe Vitale | Vitale is one of the harder decisions to make. He's probably not going to get much better than he is now, which is playing 4th line center. His salary of just under 600k was a bargain price, but if you are signing Goc (or if he signs), there isn't much place for Vitale. Vitale is good on faceoffs, but just barely an NHL talent. This might just have to be a situation where the Pens let the 28 year old walk, then look at him in free agency if they can't find a better replacement. | I just said it: Let him walk, try and do better or look at signing him in free agency. |
| Chris Conner | Chris Connor is a speedy player never had a good season outside the Penguins' organization. He played for 550k this season, but spent most of it either in the Minors or injured on the NHL club. Ho-hum stats, 30 years old. See ya. | Maybe we should get a bunch of cardboard boxes. Seems like there's some guys who will need them. Connor's another. |
| Harry Zolnierczyk | 'Harry Z' may end up being a beneficiary of the Penguins being where they are right now. At only 26, and still unproven at the NHL level, he would be a cheap re-sign, and could fill in at a bottom-6 role until things are back on track for the Pens, cap-wise. | 2 Years, 600k per |
| Brian Gibbons | Brian Gibbons had a breakout season this year, his first in the NHL. While his 17 points in 41 games is respectable, he did have the benefit of spending a good deal of the season getting chances to play with other talent--including several games on Sidney Crosby's wing. He undoubtedly has speed to kill, but because of poor contract management, the 26-year-old is eligible for UFA status. If he wants to test the market, he's gone. The biggest problem I have with Gibbons, from a GM's perspective, is how much will it take to sign him, and where is the ceiling. I feel he could draw maybe a little over 1 mil on the open market, but I also feel like the Pens could keep him with a lesser offer | I think you really want to sign Gibbons for another 2 years, see what happens. Maybe 900k per season; Maybe as high as 1.15 mil. |
| Spencer Machacek* | Spencer Machacek, as well as the next 2 UFAs on this list, I don't really know enough about to make a fair assessment. I don't follow Wilkes-Barre as well as I should, so this will all be based off what the number tell me. 33 points in 55 games between WB and Springfield isn't bad, and at 25, he's still young. However, the 625 he made this season is a little too much. I'd give him 2 more years at 550k, or 1 year at 600k | 2 years at 550k, or 1 year at 600k. From there, you can figure out if he'll ever cut it. |
| Nick Drazenovic* | Drazenovic, like Spencer Machacek, is another player who came to Pittsburgh out of Columbus' system. His points dipped this season from 53 in 64 games to 41 in 63 games. He made league minimum this year, but unless he's some kind of lockerroom leader, I'm letting him walk and looking for someone a little younger | Let him walk, there are usually plenty of young centers with something to prove on the market. |
| Zach Sill* | Although the stats don't say much, Sill is only 25 and making league minimum. You could probably consider giving him a small raise for making 20 games at the NHL level this season, keep him till he's 27 and see what he can do. | 2 Years, 575k per |
| RFAs | TH's Thoughts | What TH would do |
| Brandon Sutter | Sutter is another tough decision that has to be made. His currently expiring contract had a cap hit a little bit over 2 mil per season, and he is going to want a raise. At 25, he still has some room to improve, and he finally seemed to be hitting his stride for the first time since coming to the Penguins towards the end of last year. While it's probably safe to say that he'll never hit his career high of 40 points playing 3rd line center, he could break it if he shows up strong next season. Of course, that'll require a contract. Based on his salary, he'll require a qualifying offer of his current salary, 2.7 mil. If you intend to play him at 2nd line center (Malkin permanently with Sid), a salary increase makes sense. Of course, it'll either look really smart if he has hit his stride, or really bad, if he's going to regress again | Offer a 4 year deal, 3.5 mil cap hit. 3 mil first season, then 3.4, 3.6, 4 mil final season. Maybe come in low and match this on scoring bonuses. If he doesn't want it, he's qualified, let him sit the season out or sign an offer sheet. You can always shift Malkin back into his 2nd line center role. |
| Jayson Megna | The qualifying offer for the 24-year-old comes out to about 875k. As much as he made the NHL level last season, and impressed (depsite lack of production), I'm not going any higher than this, and probably not longer than 2 years. | Qualify him at 875k, 2 years. See what the kid can do. |
| Bobby Farnham* | You have to like a kid who worked his way up from the ECHL. Unfortunately, the 25-year-old Farnham doesn't seem to have much more going for him than being a fighter...and being another short guy at 5'10". He's an RFA making league minimum, but it will cost 605k to qualify him. I just don't know that you can spend that much cap on someone who I don't really believe can cut it in the NHL. | Let him walk. His career is probably done in the NHL/AHL. |
|